Return to front page

Newest article: Re: PA system at SJP by ktfcprogrammes7328/9/2023 23:09Thu Sep 28 23:09:24 2023view thread

Oldest article: "Hither & Thither"? by alan ainsworth24/11/2013 12:59Sun Nov 24 12:59:08 2013view thread


Next thread: Pleased as punch! by rwakeley21/2/2018 21:52Wed Feb 21 21:52:42 2018view thread

Some more thoughts

By rwakeley19/2/2018 18:17Mon Feb 19 18:17:24 2018

Views: 2381

Having re-gained our play-off status, I decided, having sobered up sometime on Sunday, to look at play-off history.
Home advantage, not surprisingly, is a big advantage. One thing did stand out.
On only 3 occasions out of 13 seasons has a side clinched promotion away from home in the final.
Even more remarkable over such a time-frame, no team has been promoted having finished 5th!
With this years feeder leagues now seeing promotion play-offs down to 7th - one does have to question the credibility of such a venture. No doubt different opinions prevail. Personally, I believe that is stretching it somewhat. Not at least in the credibility stakes.
I also looked into the Ryman North and South back to 2006/07 post re-structuring and only once, Canvey Island 2007-08, has a team been promoted having finished 5th! That's 35 separate divisions of football, over the period, with only one team gaining promotion having finished 5th.
Why it has proved so difficult - again opinions - Should we finish 5th, I would not unduly perceive it as such a huge obstacle - history suggests otherwise.
OK then lads - just finnish fourth - or do it the hard way - either way.
Good luck lads versus Barnet - I want a May final - the play-offs can wait.

Edited by rwakeley at 18:21:19 on 19th February 2018

reply to this article | return to the front page

Re: Some more thoughts

By John Rogers20/2/2018 09:19Tue Feb 20 09:19:14 2018In response to Some more thoughtsTop of thread

Views: 2383

Having 6 teams playing off for promotion is such a silly notion it's unreal. Although I know the odds are stacked against the sides finishing 6th & 7th, were one of those clubs to gain promotion then a season's worth of mediocrity has been rewarded inside the space of 10 days.

Those stats you quote above, Rob, are interesting. Only one fifth placed finisher has managed to gain promotion in the Isthmian League over the past decade and a bit. Personally speaking, were we to finish in the next four behind the champs, I'd fancy us to beat anyone ('ricay included) at home - away from home, less so. That said, in the past couple of months it's our away form that has impressed and our home form that has dipped.

Conclusion? None to be drawn.

Still plenty of work to be done between now and then, however.

reply to this article | return to the front page

Re: Some more thoughts

By Mike Cox20/2/2018 17:18Tue Feb 20 17:18:21 2018In response to Re: Some more thoughtsTop of thread

Views: 2332

While the chance of a play off place may well keep the season alive for clubs in or about the top half of the table, I still maintain, dear old fashioned chap that I am, that the team finishing 2nd having proved itself over 46 games should go up with the champions. As we know to our cost, a team finishing perhaps 10 or more points below can be promoted on the basis of just 2 play off games.

reply to this article | return to the front page

Previous thread: Kingstonian v Hendon by Ks Prog18/2/2018 20:04Sun Feb 18 20:04:48 2018view thread